Cow Patty's
154 Route 23
Wantage Township, NJ 07461
973-997-7515
Burger-focused roadside restaurant with wings, sandwiches, salads and shakes. Current menu offers a gluten-free bun.
GF
Wantage Township
Food & Drink
Current restaurants, diners, bakeries, delis, farm-market food and bars across Wantage's Route 23 and rural corridors.
No currently verified listings match this filter. NJTGO only assigns GF/DF badges where current menu or allergen information supports them.
Allergy & cross-contact caution: GF and DF badges identify currently documented choices or accommodations, not an allergen-free kitchen. Shared fryers, grills, prep surfaces and ingredient changes can create cross-contact. Diners with celiac disease or food allergies should confirm current preparation directly before ordering.
Burgers & American
Diners & Breakfast
New Airport Diner
51 County Road 639
Wantage Township, NJ 07461
973-702-1025
Classic diner at Sussex Airport with all-day breakfast, sandwiches and comfort food.
Sussex Sit n' Chat Diner
289 Route 23
Wantage Township, NJ 07461
973-702-7321
Traditional New Jersey diner with a broad breakfast, lunch and dinner menu.
Pizza & Italian
Brothers Pizza & Italian Restaurant
455 Route 23
Wantage Township, NJ 07461
973-702-1436
Pizza, Italian-American dinners, subs, catering and delivery. Current menu explicitly offers gluten-free pasta.
GF
Frank's Pizza & Restaurant
205 Route 23
Wantage Township, NJ 07461
973-875-1250
Family-run pizzeria and Italian-American restaurant.
Pizza, Deli & Cafe
Up The Creek Cafe & Pizzeria
1214 Route 23, Building B
Wantage Township, NJ 07461
973-702-1400
Family-run café, deli and pizzeria in the Colesville section of Wantage.
Indian
Indian Spice Route 23
455 Route 23
Wantage Township, NJ 07461
973-298-0252
Modern Indian restaurant with curries, tandoori dishes, Indo-Chinese specialties, weekend buffet and full beverage program.
Asian
Eastern Garden
455 Route 23
Wantage Township, NJ 07461
973-875-0089
Chinese and Japanese dishes, sushi, takeout and delivery.
Yamato Hibachi Steakhouse
205 Route 23
Wantage Township, NJ 07461
973-875-1414
Japanese hibachi, sushi, sashimi and Asian-fusion menu.
Greek & Italian
The Green Olive
1 Libertyville Rd
Wantage Township, NJ 07461
973-702-1011
Sit-down restaurant and bar with Greek, Italian and American dishes.
Bakery, Deli & Market
Clove Brook Market
800 Route 23
Wantage Township, NJ 07461
973-875-5600
Award-winning bakery, deli, prepared foods and catering market serving Wantage since 2003.
Bakery
Holland American Bakery
246 Route 23
Wantage Township, NJ 07461
973-875-5258
Long-running Dutch-American bakery with pastries, breads, cakes and breakfast favorites.
Deli & Quick Service
Quick Stop Deli
81 Route 23
Wantage Township, NJ 07461
973-875-3768
Local deli and convenience-food stop.
Specialty Food
Sussex Meat Packing
205 Route 23
Wantage Township, NJ 07461
973-875-5641
Butcher shop and specialty meat market.
Farm Market & Creamery
Green Valley Farms Market & Creamery
997 Route 23
Wantage Township, NJ 07461
973-875-5213
Farm market, local goods, produce and homemade ice cream in a family-friendly farm setting.
Bars & Beverage
Airport Pub & Package
65 County Road 639
Wantage Township, NJ 07461
973-702-1215
Neighborhood pub and packaged-goods business near Sussex Airport.
Skylands Craft Beer & Wine Garden
447 Route 284
Wantage Township, NJ 07461
Beer and wine garden with live entertainment and casual bar snacks.
Attraction Dining
Extreme Pizza at Space Farms
218 Route 519
Wantage Township, NJ 07461
Casual pizza and family food service inside Space Farms Zoo & Museum during attraction operating periods.
Dietary verification: Cow Patty's current menu lists a gluten-free bun as a standard bun choice. Brothers Pizza's current menu explicitly lists gluten-free pasta. No DF badge is shown unless current information clearly supports a dairy-free choice; the DF filter remains available and will show a no-results message when no listing is currently verified.
Current-operation note: Elias Cole Restaurant, a longtime Wantage landmark, closed after service on July 26, 2026 and is therefore not listed as a current restaurant.